have you read this book before?

来源：学生作业帮编辑：灵鹊做题网作业帮分类：英语作业时间：2024/04/28 22:05:00

have you read this book before?
yes i have
no i haven"t
是不是错的?
就象did't you speak to him yesterday?
yse i did
no i didn't一样
是不是应该是haven't you read this book before?

我想很多朋友都理解错了楼主的问题.楼主想问的应该是关于反义疑问句的问题.
这个问题是中国人常搞不清楚的一个问题
这是因为英文是对事实本身回答yes或no
比如didn't you speak to him yesterday?你昨天没和他说话吗?
回答yes,i did.是说我和他说话了,这里yes是对说话这件事表示肯定
而中国人回答是对提问的整个句子表示肯定或否定,回答“是的,我没有”这里“是的”是对提问者的问话表示肯定,意思是,“你说对了”
所以不管你是问didn't you speak to him yesterday?还是did you speak to him yesterday?回答都是yes,i did或no,i didn't.表示的意思也是一样的“是的,我和他说话了”“不,我没和他说话”
对于提问者来说,否定疑问（didn't you）有一定的反诘疑问,有“难道你没...”的意思,但不一定很强烈.有时就和did you一样.
对于时态,这里用完成时后面跟before没有任何问题.字典里的例句就是i have never met him before.

have you read this book before? have you read this book? Have you read this book yet? you haven't read the book before ,have you?____ He ()(read) this book before. have you read this book?do you read this book?为什么疑问词要用have 而 Have you ever _______(read ) this book Yes ,I have. 1,Have you read any books ____ this subject before? I have read this book 英语时态题have you finished _____(read)this book? Have you read this book?It's worth reading.汉译 have you read this book ___?A already B yet